The smart Trick of atlantic corp case solutions That No One is Discussing

“In mild of current experiences on the current human legal rights circumstance of migrants in Libya, handing people today more than towards the Libyan authorities or other teams in Libya would expose them to a true risk of torture or inhuman or degrading therapy or punishment… I could be grateful if you can make clear the kind of assistance functions your governing administration expects to offer to the Libyan authorities in Libyan territorial waters and what safeguards Italy has place in place in order that men and women intercepted or rescued by Italian vessels in Libyan territorial waters tend not to subsequently experience a condition contrary to Posting 3 of the European Conference on Human Legal rights.

The case of Ortho-McNeil Pharm., Inc. v. Mylan Labs, Inc., 520 File.3d 1358, 86 USPQ2d 1196 (Fed. Cir. 2008), delivers A further example through which a chemical compound was firm not to be obvious. The claimed subject material was topiramate, that is utilised as an anti-convulsant. In the middle of Doing work toward a brand new anti-diabetic drug, Ortho-McNeil’s scientist had unexpectedly found that a response intermediate had anti-convulsant Qualities. Mylan’s defense of invalidity due to obviousness rested on an clear to test argument. Even so, Mylan didn't demonstrate why it would have been clear to start with an anti-diabetic drug precursor, especially the precise one that led to topiramate, if one were seeking an anti-convulsant drug. The district courtroom dominated on summary judgment that Ortho-McNeil’s patent was not invalid for obviousness. The Federal Circuit affirmed. The Federal Circuit pointed out that there was no clear rationale a person of standard talent might have preferred the particular setting up compound or the particular artificial pathway that resulted in topiramate being an intermediate. Moreover, there would've been no cause to check that intermediate for anticonvulsant Attributes if treating diabetes had been the target.

What has ensued has actually been the generation of various new alliances. Many militias Earlier aligned to opposing factions of the 2014 Dawn and Dignity coalitions are uniting underneath Juwaili’s command and deploying to positions south of Wershefana.

The former is much more probable for many motives. Regardless of the uproar with regard to the massacre and airstrikes at the moment, it is actually not likely to become sustained. The Intercontinental Neighborhood have looked the opposite way so persistently right before that there's no authentic rationale to expect that to change this time. Haftar’s hardcore supporters will go on to guidance him whatever, probable viewing some collateral harm as an appropriate price to pay to defeat the ‘terrorists’.

And it relies upon we wouldn’t choose to – I feel we wouldn’t need to use coal chance as well as service provider possibility. We don’t want any coal chance that includes environmental difficulties just like the coal that isn't well scrubbed or that they had any type of local land use concerns, but should they have been stable on All those issues, depending upon the condition that you are in, we’d be ready to buy coal plants that are crucial to your grid if we can get the best returns on them.

The claimed find out invention in Alza Corp. v. Mylan Labs., Inc., 464 File.3d 1286, eighty USPQ2d 1001 (Fed. Cir. 2006) was drawn to sustained-launch formulations of the drug oxybutynin during which the drug is released in a specified charge above a 24-hour time period. Oxybutynin was identified to be extremely h2o-soluble, plus the specification had identified that advancement of sustained-launch formulations of these kinds of drugs introduced individual challenges. A previous artwork patent to Morella experienced taught sustained-release compositions of really water-soluble medicines, as exemplified by a sustained-launch formulation of morphine. Morella had also recognized oxybutynin as belonging to The category of hugely h2o-soluble medications. The Baichwal prior art patent had taught a sustained-launch formulation of oxybutynin that had another release level in comparison to the claimed invention. Lastly, the Wong prior art patent had taught a usually applicable system for supply of medications over a 24-hour interval.

Recruiting them on their individual deserves, an making sure They can be strictly disciplined and accountable, is a more possible alternative.

The prior art (Kammiller) disclosed disabling the inverter while in the occasion of a higher-load existing condition in order to protect the inverter circuit. That may be, the overload protection was realized by disabling the inverter by means of a cutoff swap. The courtroom identified “it might have been clear to at least one of ordinary talent within the artwork to employ the brink sign generated in the USSR gadget to actuate a cutoff switch to render the inverter inoperative as taught by Kammiller.” Id. at 1403, seven USPQ2d at 1502. That is, utilizing the recognised procedure of the cutoff change for safeguarding a circuit to deliver the defense wanted from the inverter circuit of your USSR document would've been obvious to at least one of regular skill. Illustration two:

Very first, Libya needs a de-conflicting system to avoid escalation. When the U.N. envoy are unable to do it, someone else from the West should. What much better possibility for Britain to point out its ongoing relevance soon after Brexit than this? Or Why don't you the French international minister, who could beef up his legacy just months just before leaving office?

Libya’s NOC had declared pressure majeure on Sharara crude previous Tuesday, a clause which relieves it from delivery obligations as a result of situation outside its control.

To his quite a few overseas people, Haftar has explained over and over that he’s not Prepared to simply accept civilian oversight. His present in Abu Dhabi will be to be The top in the navy and its civilian commander, all in one individual and concurrently.

Management's organized remarks along with the accompanying presentation for modern get in touch with and webcast can be found during the Meeting Connect with section of our Web-site.

Such a overall body can be step by step designed up, as being the militias are progressively scaled down, to stay away from any severe protection vacuum that will deliver about more criminality and violence.

So is the risk more details on them likely like building their unique kind of in-home electrical power facility? Like is it they don’t require your facility, is it more details on them perhaps bringing a little something in just their headquarter campus?

5 Tips about atlantic corp case study analysis You Can Use Today

Phipps Conservatory and Botanical Garden’s mission is always to encourage and teach all Together with the splendor and significance of plants, advance sustainability and human and environmental wellbeing as a result of motion and investigation, and also to rejoice its historic glass residences. The mission on the Business is apparent in the middle for Sustainable Landscapes (CSL).

“Generally the main challenge with computer software coding—And that i’m a coder myself,” Bantégnie says, “isn't the techniques in the coders. The folks learn how to code. The condition is what

As President Trump and Exclusive Counsel Robert Mueller keep on to dance around the possibility of an interview, it's, Maybe, beneficial to consider how a confrontation among The 2 may possibly play out.

The idea is the fact if one thing goes Mistaken, you’re equipped to determine why; the exercise brings order and accountability to substantial codebases. But, Shivappa states, “it’s a very labor-intensive system.” He estimates that before they applied product-based mostly style, over a two-year-very long task only two to 3 months was spent creating code—The remainder was put in working on the documentation.

"Could you cover an unforeseen $four hundred expenditure? Four in ten People in america can not, As outlined by a new report within the Federal Reserve Board. People that do not have the cash readily available say they'd must protect it by borrowing or marketing a thing....'This year's survey finds that soaring amounts of employment are translating into enhanced fiscal disorders For a lot of but not all Individuals,' Federal Reserve Board Governor Lael Brainard explained in a push launch...a lot of remain battling. Notable dissimilarities stay throughout race, ethnicity, education and learning concentrations and geography. The report exhibits hardship proceeds for folks Operating to repay school financial loans, go over unexpected emergency fees and handle retirement cost savings....'The obtaining that four-in-ten Older people couldn't deal with an unexpected $four hundred expenditure with out promoting a little something or borrowing income is troubling,' stated Greg McBride, Main money analyst at Bankrate.

The simultaneous failure of a great number of program methods smelled at the outset of the coordinated cyberattack. Pretty much extra terrifying was the realization, late while in the working day, that it had been just a coincidence.

Economic impotence has many of the properties of sexual impotence, not least of which is the Determined have to mask it.

The converse, which went viral when it absolutely was posted on the internet in February 2012, seemed to be making two Daring promises. The very first was that the way we make computer software is fundamentally damaged. The second was that Victor knew how to fix it.

All irrigation, toilet flushing and janitorial and devices makes use of are equipped by captured rainwater. Roof runoff from each the CSL and an adjacent, non-task framework, is captured within a 1500-gallon cistern employed for landscape irrigation (when necessary). Any overflow is diverted right into a around a hundred,000-gallon lagoon. The lagoon serves as a landscape aspect, a home to indigenous turtles and fish and is also available to visitors via a bordering boardwalk. Wetland crops purify the drinking water, and lagoon overflow is channeled into underground rain tanks with sixty,000 gallon ability.

...Now, with Trump and his go-drill, rather than no-drill, policy from the White Property, the politics of oil exploration have transformed. Will the US buy into that policy?....There truly isn't a scarcity of oil on this planet - not like when OPEC made problems in the nineteen seventies....So what's the situation? With gasoline inventories up, selling prices needs to be going down. That’s where economical speculators can be found in. With Venezuela's financial state collapsing and Iran under Intercontinental force thanks to its nuclear insurance policies, Wall Street is expecting all the generation numbers to fall quickly." forty% of usa citizens are unable to go over a $400 emergency cost -CNN Income

The theory was that you make something trusted by generating its areas trustworthy (say, you Make your engine to face up to 40,000 takeoff-and-landing cycles) and by arranging for that go to the website breakdown of those sections (you've two engines). But application doesn’t break

Lamport sees this failure to think mathematically about the things they’re performing as the situation of modern software advancement inside of a nutshell: The stakes continue to keep mounting, but programmers aren’t stepping up—they haven’t developed the chops required to handle increasingly sophisticated problems.

Following her partner was killed in a detest crime in Kansas, an American immigrant reevaluates her desire on the region.

A steep, thirty foot drop in elevation from the prevailing campus to decrease degree of the making delivered the opportunity to create a environmentally friendly roof within the making that is straight obtainable from the present adjacent terraces, Consequently blurring the connection between setting up construction (roof) and garden landscapes (floor).

The Basic Principles Of atlantic corp case solutions

8+ decades of constant and progressive arms-on practical experience that has a Bachelors in Personal computer Science or related industry.

Communications: Ability to speak Evidently and competently to group associates and consumers, verbally As well as in creating. In a position to current ideas in many different methods based upon viewers and context.

Disseminate information on methods available to Soldiers and loved ones marketing Standard of living alternatives

Audits recent info protection constraints such as entry to community assets or details and propose corrective motion options, as required.

The silver lining beneath Trump's withdrawal within the Paris Local weather Arrangement is usually that we are looking at action on the city and condition level like we have by no means viewed prior to.

New research implies there may be no wild indigenous honey bees left in England and Wales, but how much does their disappearance issue?

Maryland will be the 3rd state to ban fracking, but that is entirely individual from the specter of pipelines. Despite having two.7 million miles of pipelines throughout the US, there are actually ideas

A steep, 30 foot fall in elevation from the present campus to reduced standard of the constructing supplied the opportunity to create a inexperienced roof on the creating that is right obtainable from the present adjacent terraces, Hence blurring site web the connection between constructing construction (roof) and garden landscapes (floor).

Proof of work, qualifications screening, and protection clearance/favorable background check is required ahead of an ID CAC might be issued authorizing entry to governing administration Pc systems.

The claimed invention in Ex parte Smith, eighty three USPQ2d 1509 (Bd. Pat. Application. & Int. 2007), was a pocket insert for any bound guide made by gluing a base sheet along with a pocket sheet of paper jointly to variety a continual two-ply seam defining a closed pocket. The prior art (Wyant) disclosed a minimum of 1 pocket shaped by folding only one sheet and securing the folder parts together the inside margins using any practical bonding system. The prior artwork (Wyant) did not disclose bonding the sheets to sort a ongoing two-ply seam. The prior art (Dick) disclosed a pocket which is created by stitching or if not securing two sheets along a few of its four edges to outline a closed pocket with a gap alongside its fourth edge.

Liaison with product or service distributors regarding defects in software package/hardware supported from the Network Expert services group, and active management of such defects (like the development of momentary fixes) by means of to resolution.

Function with business enterprise end users to develop and carry out timing and acceptance test approach to make certain merchandise satisfies customer demands and anticipations.

Safety, integrity and confidential of knowledge is of paramount importance. CGIP Facts System support focuses on supplying trustworthy and readily available info technological innovation solutions to assist in making certain the Coastline Guard maintains final decision benefit in executing all of its myriad missions.

Working experience tracking task exercise; resolving difficulties; publishing development stories; recommending steps.

The Fact About atlantic corp case solutions That No One Is Suggesting

The corporate also generates synthetic lubricant foundation stocks in addition to lubricant additives, propylene packaging films and catalysts. The company was an industry chief in metallocene catalyst know-how for making exclusive polymers with enhanced performance.[citation desired] ExxonMobil is the largest producer of butyl rubber.[106]

    The grievance makes its closest go in a predicate for conspiracy Together with the claim that collusion was vital due to the fact results by even just one CLEC in an ILEC’s territory “would have exposed the degree to which competitive entry by CLECs would have been successful in another territories.” Id., ¶50, Application. 26–27. But, its logic aside, this common premise still fails to reply The purpose that there was just no need to have for joint encouragement to resist the 1996 Act; since the District Court said, “Each individual ILEC has purpose to want to avoid addressing CLECs” and “Every single ILEC would make an effort to preserve CLECs out, whatever the steps of one other ILECs.” 313 F. Supp. 2d, at 184; cf. Kramer v. Pollock-Krasner Foundation, 890 File. Supp. 250, 256 (SDNY 1995) (whilst the plaintiff “may possibly consider the defendants conspired … , the defendants’ allegedly conspiratorial actions could Similarly are already prompted by lawful, independent plans which usually do not constitute a conspiracy”).12     Plaintiffs’ second conspiracy principle rests to the aggressive reticence Among the many ILECs by themselves while in the wake in the 1996 Act, which was supposedly passed within the “ ‘hop[e] that the massive incumbent nearby monopoly organizations … could assault their neighbors’ service areas, as They can be the ideal positioned to do so.

Although the SSR only permits era of the audio equivalent to the main letter of the word, it does so working with electronic signifies. The mix is Consequently the adaptation of an aged concept or invention (Bevan) utilizing more recent technology that is usually accessible and understood in the art (the SSR).” The courtroom uncovered that the claimed creation was but a variation on previously regarded kids’s toys. This variation presented no nonobvious advance more than other toys. The court manufactured obvious that there was no technological progress past the ability revealed while in the SSR system. The court located that “[a]ccomodating a previous art mechanical unit that accomplishes that purpose to modern electronics would have been fairly apparent to 1 of standard talent in building kids’s Understanding products. Implementing contemporary electronics to more mature mechanical gadgets has been commonplace lately.” Illustration 3:

Atlantic Pc Case Introduction: Jason Jowers, who experienced a short while ago been employed by the computer maker, Atlantic Computer system, required to devise a pricing prepare for the organization’s newest goods: The Atlantic Bundle. This bundle contained the Tronn server and its corresponding program, the PESA. Soon after an First marketing meeting with a number of essential players, Jowers experienced enter from The pinnacle with the server division (Matzer), the director from the division’s R&D team (Jones), and the director of new item advertising (Fowler). On top of that, Jowers also has to just take into account the thoughts in the gross sales Section, guide by Jairo Cadena. Atlantic’s biggest competitor is Ontario Pc, Inc, that is a value cutter during the industry, and Atlantic Computer must Keep in mind The purchasers and items that Ontario is soon after in addition. External Analysis: The need for World-wide-web servers in the united states’s workplace is often a rising market, with quite a few unique segments.

The report discusses the strategic, operation and fiscal components of the acquisition. The major locations discussed involve:

As in depth inside our Privacy Plan We're going to use your individual information and facts to administer your account and provide the services and products that you have asked for from us.

Combined with the new name, Exxon settled on a rectangular symbol using crimson lettering and blue trim with a white background, just like the acquainted coloration plan about the old Enco and Esso logos. Exxon replaced the Esso, Enco, and Humble brand names in America on January one, 1973.[citation required]

Zara has good network of distribution channels to cater the desires of consumers. It is highly commendable that Zara converts a concept into an item in just 15 times as compared to the common business regular as six months. This sort of is huge big difference of ‘velocity’. It offers custom made touch to Zara prospects.

The claimed creation in In re O’Farrell, 853 File.second 894, seven USPQ2d 1673 (Fed. Cir. 1988) was directed to a way for synthesizing a protein within a transformed bacterial host species by substituting a heterologous gene for a gene native on the host species. Generally speaking, protein synthesis in vivo follows a path from DNA to mRNA. Although the prior art Polisky short article (authored by two on the three inventors of the applying) had explicitly suggested utilizing the tactic described for protein synthesis, the inserted heterologous gene exemplified from the posting was one that Typically did not continue all of the method to the protein manufacturing step, but in its place terminated with the mRNA. A 2nd reference to Bahl had described a typical technique of inserting chemically synthesized DNA into a plasmid. As a result, it would've been evident to one of standard skill from the artwork to replace the prior artwork gene with another gene recognised to bring about protein production, simply because one of standard talent in the art would've been able to carry out such a substitution, and the outcomes were reasonably predictable.

ten If your criticism experienced not defined which the claim of arrangement rested to the parallel perform described, we doubt the grievance’s references to an agreement Amongst the ILECs would have offered the discover expected by Rule eight. Other than determining a seven-12 months span through which the §1 violations had been supposed to have transpired (i.e., “[b]eginning at the least as early as February 6, 1996, and continuing on the existing,” id., ¶sixty four, App. thirty), the pleadings described no unique time, spot, or man or woman involved with the alleged conspiracies. This lack of see contrasts sharply with the product sort for pleading carelessness, Kind nine, which the dissent states exemplifies the sort of “bare allegation” that survives a movement to dismiss.

Termination legal rights, which may be activated by a breach of contract, a failure to fulfill sure disorders or even the passage of a specific timeframe without having consummating the transaction, and costs and damages payable in case of the termination for sure occasions (often called breakup costs).

On top of that, The truth that the counterweight mechanism from Teague made use of a big spring, which appellant argued would overpower the treadmill mechanism, ignores the modifications that just one competent while in the artwork would make to a tool borrowed in the prior artwork. A person competent within the artwork would size the components from Teague correctly for the applying. ICON is yet another useful example for knowing the scope of analogous artwork. The artwork utilized involved retaining mechanisms for folding beds, not treadmills. When analyzing whether a reference might adequately be applied to an invention in a different area of endeavor, it's important to look at the problem to generally be solved. It is definitely feasible that a reference could be drawn in such a way that its usefulness for a teaching is narrowly limited. Having said that, in ICON, the problem being solved wasn't restricted to the educating from the “treadmill” notion. The Teague reference was analogous artwork because “Teague and The existing software equally deal with the necessity to stably retain a folding mechanism,” and since “almost nothing about ICON’s folding system requires any individual focus on treadmills,” Id. at 1378, 1380, 83 USPQ2d at 1749-50. ICON is likewise informative concerning the connection between the challenge to generally be solved and existence of a explanation to mix. “In fact, although Possibly not dispositive of The problem, the locating that Teague, by addressing the same difficulty, supplies analogous artwork to ICON’s software goes a great distance to demonstrating a reason to mix the two references. Due to the fact ICON’s broad statements read on embodiments addressing that issue as explained by Teague, the prior artwork here suggests a explanation to incorporate its teachings.” Id. at 1380-81, 83 USPQ2d at 1751. The Federal Circuit’s dialogue in ICON also will make clear that When the reference does not instruct that a mixture is undesirable, then it can not be explained to show away. An assessment of no matter if a mixture would render the system inoperable have to not “ignore the modifications that 1 proficient during the artwork would make to a tool borrowed from your prior art.” Id. at 1382, eighty three USPQ2d at 1752. Instance six:

Discoveries created while in the study lab will play an integral job in furthering ambitious CSL-based training and outreach initiatives likewise and include interactive, mother nature-centered applications for both general public and school groups that exhibit the value of crops, science and sustainability. ­

To reject a assert based on this rationale, Business staff need to solve the Graham factual inquiries. Then, Office personnel have to articulate the next: (1) a discovering that the prior artwork contained a tool (approach, product, etcetera.) which differed from the claimed device because of the substitution of some components (action, component, and so forth.) with other elements; (2) a getting which the substituted parts as well as their capabilities had been recognized during the artwork; (three) a discovering that among ordinary ability inside the artwork could have substituted one recognised aspect for an additional, and the outcome on the visit our website substitution might have been predictable; and (4) whatsoever extra conclusions according to the Graham factual inquiries could be necessary, in see with the details of the case under consideration, to elucidate a summary of obviousness.

Top latest Five atlantic corp case study solution Urban news

Plenty of emphasis continues to be put on the idea that Iceland possesses massive amounts of “inexperienced Power,” this means that this Electrical power won't melt away fossil fuels. Thereby it's assumed that no CO2 emission usually takes place. This is, on the other hand, much from the truth: in 2008 the CO2 emission from geothermal vegetation in Iceland amounted to 185 thousand tons, which is six% in the region’s total CO2 emission1. Hydro dams also add to the amount of carbon from the ambiance: big reservoirs result in the drowning of vegetated land, wherein rotting vegetation emits methane gasoline, growing world-wide warming. It's estimated that about seven% of carbon emitted by humans originate from this sort of constructions2. The sediment of glacial rivers influences the ocean’s ecosystems and nourishes algae vegetation via the seashore.

Using this type of in your mind it is necessary to take into consideration that in the future many years, this emphasis on mother nature conservation is likely to enhance even even more. As a result it is necessary with the Industries Committee to understand that retaining normal regions in pending won't stop future utilization, whereas locations exploited nowadays can not be secured tomorrow.

Right now, this heritage of excellence serves for a System to display that people along with the all-natural globe are inextricably joined, and that sustainable action is The true secret to making sure that crucial interconnections are preserved for foreseeable future generations.

Finest set into phrases by the former Key Minister Jóhanna Sigurðardóttir: “The existing federal government’s priorities could not be much more different from those honored by the last a single. Inequality is Yet again rearing its unattractive head, and the sharp knife of austerity is turned in the direction of the welfare technique—all to profit Culture’s wealthiest and best-off. Once more, the wheels of greed are spinning”

The open up Workplace ground with a raised access flooring technique allows for versatility and adaptability For a long time to come back. The general setting up methods are plug-and-Perform and easily upgradeable to accommodate technological advancements. A shut-loop, complete nutrient biking administration strategy aims to realize a zero-squander internet site; all biomass is recycled in-situ and custom made compost tea mixes are applied to assistance the various website habitats and sustain biodiversity to the challenge site over time.

Saving Iceland has posted one of the remarks, prepared by Helga Katrín Tryggvadóttir, which differs from these two teams since it evaluates Electricity manufacturing and mother nature conservation in a larger, long-time period context.

A big atrium, majorly-manufactured of concrete functions to be a heat sink by supporting control the temperature all through the course of the day. Phase improve materials that traces the atrium walls also passively control temperature. In-depth, computational fluid dynamics experiments identified placement for BAS- and occupant-controlled windows To optimize purely natural air flow. These passive techniques, which also involves operable windows for natural ventilation, permitted a downsized mechanical process (a custom-constructed rooftop Electricity Restoration unit).

Japan ex-PM Nakasone, witness to war and accomplishment, turns a hundred It really is in some way fitting in a country noted for longevity that one among Japan's most notable former leaders has attained a hundred several years of age

Environmentalist and journalist Ómar Ragnarsson, who originally learned the lagoons, adopted the story by publishing his own images of comparable lakes made by other geothermal crops, which include Those people because of the plants at Reykjanes, Svartsengi, Nesjavellir and Bjarnarflag1. These lakes can be extremely unsafe to regional freshwater units, as Saving Iceland’s Jaap Krater and Miriam Rose make clear in a very ebook chapter on the event of geothermal harnessing in Iceland:

Stóra-Sandvík is a singular geothermal field inside of a coastal see this here spot close to the municipalities of Grindavík and Hafnir, as well as into the Reykjanesvirkjun plant, which in by itself must be cause ample to maneuver it with the exploitation category and instead to defense.

The look staff’s approach to Electricity efficiency was to use exterior-in, passive approaches initial. To this stop, the atrium was intended to dwelling massive amounts of concrete to work as thermal mass, growing Strength effectiveness. Having said that, concrete embodies significant amounts of carbon relative to other elements due to its producing approach. To mitigate a few of this carbon, fly ash was Employed in lieu of Portland cement, One of the more water carbon intensive elements.

was shot on locale in Iceland in 2012 and can premiere at Sambíóin Egilshöll Cinema on precisely the same afternoon.

Even though they acknowledge the plant’s superior focus of polluting emissions, OR has mentioned that the business will unable to adapt to the new regulations until finally 2019 at the earliest. For that reason, the business will request an exception, to which the people of Hveragerði are closely opposed. In an interview with Iceland’s Nationwide Broadcasting Support (RÚV), the city’s Mayor Aldís Hafsteinsdóttir protested against the company’s request, stating that OR had naturally rushed way much too quick when making ready and making the plant and so underestimated its environmental impacts. Inside a independent interview with Conserving Iceland’s Miriam Rose this June, Aldís emphasized this place:

Irish election official confirms landslide victory for abortion legal rights advocates as Eire repeals constitutional ban. Irish election Formal confirms landslide victory for abortion legal rights advocates as Ireland repeals constitutional ban.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15